Our Menu
Whole Pies
Selection varies daily. Pies are $17.95-$18.95. We reserve the right to run out.
Apple Flakey
$17.95
The finest apples to be found - ranging across the seasons - are crafted into a fulfilling traditional apple pie. Topped with our traditional flakey crust.
Apple Crumb
$17.95
The finest apples to be found - ranging across the seasons - are crafted into a fulfilling traditional apple pie. Finished with our butter-crumb topping.
Apple Caramel Crumb
$18.95
Talk about gilding the lily! Mom's copper kettle caramel topping is generously drizzled over our Apple Crumb Pie for a special old-fashioned treat.
Apple Flakey Cider- Sweet
$17.95
Similar to our Apple Flakey Pie, but no sugar is added. Mom's Apple Cider is used for the slight amount of added sweetness. Available with our traditional flakey crust.
Apple Boysenberry Flakey
$17.95
Lovely dark boysenberries are combined with apples for a slightly tart pie.
Topped with our flakey crust.
Apple Boysenberry Crumb
$17.95
Lovely dark boysenberries are combined with apples for a slightly tart pie.
Topped with our crumb crust.
Apple Cherry Crumb
$17.95
Apples: yum!
Cherries: yum yum!
Together: yum yum yum!
Topped with our crumb crust.
Apple Cherry Flakey
$17.95
Apples: yum!
Cherries: yum yum!
Together: yum yum yum!
Topped with our flakey crust.
Bumbleberry Crumb
$18.95
What's a Bumbleberry? No idea! But when blackberries, blueberries and boysenberries are baked into a pie, you'll know how divine a Bumbleberry is!
Topped with our crumb crust.
Bumbleberry Flakey
$18.95
What's a Bumbleberry? No idea! But when blackberries, blueberries and boysenberries are baked into a pie, you'll know how divine a Bumbleberry is!
Topped with our flakey crust.
Cherry Flakey
$18.95
What is sweet, shiny, and red? Yes, an apple, but smaller. That’s right: cherry pie! Available with a special lattice top crust. So pretty!
Chicken Pot Pie (frozen, unbaked)
Filled with fresh ingredients our homemade Chicken Pot Pie is perfect for an afternoon lunch or a cozy dinner shared with friends and family. We roast the chicken ourselves, make gravy from scratch, and fill in with carrots, potatoes and peas. Topped with our flakey crust this savory pie makes for a hearty meal that's not to be missed!
** Chicken Pot Pies are sold as FROZEN & UNBAKED. Baking instructions provided with your order **
Chocolate Pecan
Full of nutty, chocolate goodness! Thank you Pam Mack!
Pecan
$18.95
Crunchy pecans in a just right filling. Perfection!
Pumpkin
$17.95
A seasonal favorite, creamy and gently spiced. Don’t forget the whipped cream! Available with flakey bottom crust.
Rhubarb Strawberry Crumb
$17.95
Rhubarb pie is an old Pennsylvania Dutch favorite, signaling the start of spring. Mom combines rhubarb with sweet strawberries to create a refreshing pie all year round. Topped with our crumb crust.
Rhubarb Strawberry Flakey
$17.95
Rhubarb pie is an old Pennsylvania Dutch favorite, signaling the start of spring. Mom combines rhubarb with sweet strawberries to create a refreshing pie all year round.
Topped with our flakey crust.
Pie Sides
Ice Cream
Vanilla/Cinnamon/Chocolate/Sugar-Free Vanilla. Available a la mode or by the Cup or Pint.
Whipped Cream
The real deal. Whipping cream and powdered sugar.
Sharp Cheddar Cheese
Tillamook cheese - our favorite
Caramel Sauce
Perfectly delicious - straight from our copper kettle!
Baked Goods
Apple Dumpling
A whole apple - peeled and cored, with nutmeg, brown sugar, cinnamon and goodness inside, baked in cream cheese and butter flakey crust on the outside
Brownie
Banana Nut Bread
Cookies
(Chocolate Chip / Ginger Snap / Snickerdoodle / Peanut Butter/Knipsies)
Specialty Cookies
Chocolate Peanut Butter/ Coconut Macaroon/ Lemon
Lunch
Turkey/Ham/Three Cheese Sandwich
Your choice of meat (or not) and cheese, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of bread
Chicken Pot Pie
Filled with fresh ingredients, our homemade Chicken Pot Pie is perfect for lunch. We roast the chicken ourselves, make gravy from scratch, and fill in with carrots, potatoes and peas. Topped with our flakey crust
Green Salad
Fresh greens and veggies, meat, cheese, with your choice of homemade creamy dill or apple cider herb dressings
Chocolate and Confections
English Toffee
Almond Brittle
Peanut Brittle
Fudge
Caramel Apple
With Peanuts/Without Peanuts
Box of Hand Dipped Chocolates
Approximately 1/3 of a pound of our delicious light and dark chocolates. Selection varies by box
Hand Dipped Chocolates
Choose your favorites - only in our Wynola Store
Homemade Granola
Coffee and Espresso Drinks
We feature Cafe Moto beans in our brewed coffee and espresso drinks
Regular Coffee
Cream and Sugar upon request
Decaf Coffee
Cream and Sugar upon request
Cappuccino
A shot of espresso, a shot of steamed milk, and a topping of frothed milk. Almond, Soy or Whole Milk. Served Hot or Iced.
Latte
A shot of espresso, two shots of steamed milk, topped with frothed milk. Almond, Soy or Whole Milk. Served Hot or Iced.
Espresso Shot
Served Hot or Iced.
Americano
A shot of espresso, a shot of water. Served Hot or Iced.
Apple Cider
Our delicious, freshly pressed cider
Pint
Gallon
Half Gallon
Apple Cider Vinegar
We let our delicious cider sit for a while (not too long!) and it turns into a lovely vinegar
Beverages
Lemonade
Freshly squeezed lemon juice, sugar and water - that's it!
Iced Tea
Unsweetened, Fresh Brewed
Milk
Chilled Cider
Soda
IBC Cream Soda/IBC Root Beer/7-Up/Coca Cola
Bottled Water
Hot Tea
Select your favorite Stash Tea from our selection of flavors.
Other Yummy Items
Brownie Sundae
Root Beer Float
Chocolate Sundae
Homestead Pantry Jam
Local Honey
Various flavors and sizes.